BiS melee cape vs BiS magic cape : 2007scape
Jad 2 was going to bring new BiS Capes for all styles, but players asked to do something with the Mage Arena for a new BiS Cape. What we got is not what we asked for. Even if it is more challenging than the first cape, that doesn't automatically make it acceptable. All styles got new BiS Capes this year, either released or voted.